To the CCS 2022-04 Experiments main page

Exhaustive Search with CCS on the Real-First-Order Horn Problems in the TPTP

This table shows for the 562 problems of the CNF_UNS_RFO_NEQ_HRN specialist class of TPTP 8.0.0 the proving time and compacted size of proofs by CCS in different configurations with exhaustive search.

For comparison, also known results for provers based on clausal tableaux, the connection method or model elimination are shown.

Configurations and Provers

CM+TABX
Union of CMProver, SETHEOs, lazyCoP 0.1, SATCoP 0.1. For comparison. Represents what is solvable by clausal tableaux and similar techniques.
H-1-5
Best time values of CCS in the five configurations ximp102 (aka H-1), ximp00 (aka H-2) ximp14 (aka H-3), ximp15 (aka H-4), ximp16 (aka H-5). The individual contributions of these configurations are shown in subsequent columns H-1 to H-5. The further considered configurations H-6 to H-9 do not provide proofs for additional problems.
H-1
CCS in configuration ximp102. It provides proof schemas that express hyperresolution as inference rule, which, however, is used by CCS in a goal-driven way.
H-2
CCS in configuration ximp00. A vanilla configuration that just uses condensed detachment generalized for arbitrary Horn clauses to construct proofs.
H-3
CCS in configuration ximp14. A configuration with proof schemas r0, r2, r4, r6. Highlighting indicates use of r4 or r6.
H-4
CCS in configuration ximp15. A configuration with proof schemas r1, r2, r4, r5, r6. Highlighting indicates use of r4, r5 or r6.
H-5
CCS in configuration ximp16. A configuration with proof schemas r1, r2, r3, r4, r5, r6. Highlighting indicates use of r3, r4, r5 or r6.
H-6
CCS in configuration rimp104. It provides proof schemas that express a restricted form of binary resolution. Highlighting indicates use of a shuffle proof schema, which expresses re-ordering of atoms in a clause body.
H-7
CCS in configuration ximp17. It permits the B4 combinator. Highlighting indicates use of B4.
H-8
CCS in configuration ximp11. It permits the B combinator. Highlighting indicates use of B.
H-9
CCS in configuration ximp18. It permits the B4 and C4 combinators. Highlighting indicates use of B4 or C4.
CMProver
CMProver, union of various configurations, according to http://cs.christophwernhard.com/pie/cmprover/evaluation_201803/tptp_neq.html.
TABX
Union of SETHEOs, lazyCoP 0.1, SATCoP 0.1.
SETHEOs
Union of SETHEO 3.3 and S-SETHEO according to the ProblemAndSolutionStatistics document of TPTP 8.0.0.
lazyCoP 0.1
lazyCoP 0.1 according to the ProblemAndSolutionStatistics document of TPTP 8.0.0.
SATCoP 0.1
SATCoP 0.1 according to the ProblemAndSolutionStatistics document of TPTP 8.0.0.
ProblemRatingCM-TABXH-1-5H-1H-2H-3H-4H-5H-6H-7H-8H-9CMProverSETHEOslazyCop 0.1SATCop 0.1
Totals of 562:430421413390250239236327365355351414387338394
ANA013-20.000.060.0620.1020.0620.0620.0620.0620.062
ANA037-20.000.060.0660.10100.48100.06100.07100.0810
ANA038-20.000.060.0660.10100.47100.06100.07100.0810
ANA039-20.000.060.0670.11112.24110.06110.07110.3411
ANA041-20.000.060.0600.1100.0600.0700.0600.0600.0600.0600.060
ANA042-20.000.060.0600.1000.0600.0600.0800.0600.0600.0600.060
COL101-20.000.060.0600.1100.0600.0600.0600.0500.0600.0600.060
COL102-20.000.060.0630.1140.0640.0730.0630.0640.0640.0640.064
COL104-20.000.060.0630.1040.0640.0730.0630.0640.0640.0640.064
COL105-20.000.060.0610.0920.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
COL109-20.000.060.0640.0670.0670.0640.0640.0670.0670.0670.067
COL110-20.000.060.0670.06100.09100.0770.0870.20100.06100.08100.0910
COL111-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0710.0620.0620.0620.062
COL112-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
COL113-20.000.060.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.060
COL114-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
COL115-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
COL116-20.000.060.0600.0600.0600.0600.0700.0500.0600.0600.060
COL117-20.000.060.0640.0670.0670.0640.0640.0670.0670.0670.067
COL118-20.000.060.0620.0640.0640.0620.0620.0640.0640.0640.064
COL119-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
COL120-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
COL121-20.000.060.0670.1113827.93130.35133.2113143.9613
COL122-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
COL123-20.000.060.0670.07110.56110.8281.3482.83110.10110.21110.5411
COL124-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
COM001-10.000.060.0630.0650.0650.0630.0630.0650.0650.0650.065
COM002-10.000.060.0670.07110.1490.0750.0750.78100.08110.22111.1411
GEO002-40.007.1615.6287.161329.89839.07850.1913171.1313325.1713
GRP003-10.000.050.0520.0660.0660.0660.0660.066
GRP003-20.000.060.0620.0660.0660.0660.0660.066
GRP004-10.000.050.0520.0660.0660.0660.0660.066
GRP004-20.000.060.0620.0660.0660.0660.0660.066
GRP005-10.000.060.0610.0630.0630.0630.0630.063
GRP006-10.000.060.0620.0660.0660.0660.0660.066
GRP028-10.000.060.0610.0630.0630.0630.0630.063
GRP028-30.000.060.0610.0630.0630.0630.0630.063
GRP028-40.000.060.0610.0630.0630.0630.0630.063
GRP029-20.000.060.0620.0860.3560.0760.0760.076
GRP031-20.000.060.0620.0660.0660.0660.0660.066
GRP033-30.000.060.0620.0660.0660.0660.0660.066
GRP034-40.000.060.0620.0650.0650.0660.0660.066
GRP041-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
GRP042-20.000.060.0620.0640.0640.0620.0620.0640.0640.0640.064
GRP043-20.000.060.0630.0660.0660.0630.0630.0660.0660.0660.066
GRP044-20.000.060.0620.0650.0650.0650.0650.065
GRP045-20.000.060.0630.0880.3180.0880.0980.088
GRP046-20.000.060.0630.0670.0770.0670.0670.067
GRP047-20.000.100.1040.1590.9790.1890.2290.219
GRP048-20.00155.26155.266
LAT270-20.000.050.0510.0630.0630.0630.0630.063
LAT272-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
LCL002-10.00
LCL003-10.00
LCL004-10.00105.21105.2113
LCL005-10.00
LCL006-10.000.060.0650.331041.39100.0750.07526.9690.50100.93100.7810
LCL007-10.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
LCL008-10.000.060.0650.0680.0780.0850.0650.0670.0680.0680.068
LCL009-10.000.080.0870.241210.58110.1370.18732.79100.43121.15124.1212
LCL010-10.000.060.0650.06100.1090.0650.0650.0980.06100.07100.0810
LCL011-10.000.090.0970.12110.80100.1270.1775.46100.13110.21110.3911
LCL012-10.00
LCL013-10.000.060.0620.0640.0640.0620.0620.0640.0640.0640.064
LCL014-10.0013.7113.711093.0515230.7510486.59101,406.34151,961.9614
LCL015-10.00
LCL016-10.00
LCL017-10.00
LCL018-10.00
LCL019-10.00
LCL021-10.00
LCL022-10.000.120.4180.22120.1290.3470.3970.4090.08100.19100.1110
LCL023-10.000.070.0770.07100.4190.1170.1570.10090.08100.10100.1110
LCL024-10.0010.5812.301010.5814308.4110622.621037.8414127.50142,019.1214
LCL025-10.000.150.1560.391146.68100.2160.2666.0590.34103.35110.9610
LCL026-10.00
LCL027-10.000.050.0530.0660.0660.0630.0630.0760.0660.0660.066
LCL029-10.007.777.7777.80122,269.011111.79716.137305.041030.111217.23113.2110
LCL030-10.0050.6350.63891.0813161.358277.298342.3913867.01131,140.6613
LCL032-10.00
LCL033-10.000.060.0660.0690.0880.0760.0761.0490.0790.0790.079
LCL034-10.00
LCL035-10.000.060.0650.0690.0660.0650.0650.0670.0690.0790.079
LCL036-10.00210.45738.6811210.4510443.6710
LCL038-10.00
LCL040-10.0010.0914.35819.49131,497.651110.09714.947117.541016.961251.941217.7711
LCL041-10.000.060.0630.0650.0650.0630.0630.0650.0650.0650.065
LCL042-10.0046.97493.60846.9712134.357178.6771,250.341074.2512161.2912154.3312
LCL043-10.000.060.0620.0640.0640.0620.0620.0640.0640.0640.064
LCL044-10.000.060.0630.0660.0660.0630.0630.0760.0660.0660.066
LCL045-10.000.120.1250.2296.8890.1350.15543.9690.2590.3690.369
LCL046-10.000.060.0620.0640.0640.0620.0620.0640.0640.0640.064
LCL047-10.00
LCL048-10.00
LCL049-10.00
LCL050-10.00
LCL051-10.00
LCL052-10.00
LCL053-10.00
LCL054-10.00
LCL055-10.00
LCL056-10.00
LCL057-10.00
LCL058-10.00
LCL059-10.00
LCL060-10.00
LCL064-10.000.150.1560.341137.23100.2160.2665.2590.30102.78110.9010
LCL064-20.000.090.0960.14117.83100.1260.1461.1990.13100.48110.4410
LCL065-10.000.200.2770.201132.29100.9571.77727.0290.69112.08112.8411
LCL066-10.000.280.3570.281134.24101.1072.0375.1090.27102.50110.8410
LCL067-10.00250.63867.7410250.6315
LCL068-10.00
LCL069-10.001.891.8983.87132.2174.31734.0913124.7413305.8013
LCL070-10.00241.38241.3810343.6415
LCL071-10.00
LCL072-10.000.290.2975.11130.7371.42734.9913124.6813289.3713
LCL075-10.000.120.1880.12111.31100.2770.50733.95100.17110.34110.4411
LCL076-10.000.170.1770.4111630.78110.6271.1570.92112.38113.0811
LCL076-20.000.050.0510.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
LCL076-30.000.070.0750.56104.2790.0850.09539.4490.83101.54101.4910
LCL077-10.000.070.0760.091032.45100.1160.15629.9490.16100.36100.4110
LCL077-20.000.060.0640.0880.1470.0640.0741.8680.0980.1080.108
LCL079-10.000.060.0630.0660.0660.0630.0630.0660.0660.0660.066
LCL080-10.00303.24323.689303.2414345.008545.9681,216.2114992.5513
LCL080-20.001,783.121,783.12142,378.728
LCL081-10.000.060.0660.09110.69100.0760.0761.2290.11110.16110.3211
LCL082-10.000.060.0660.11111.01100.0760.0760.8790.15110.26110.3911
LCL083-10.0011.31434.331111.31923.119872.26161,948.4813
LCL083-20.005.875.87828.111324.381015.59827.0481,630.791174.3913201.1313109.5712
LCL084-20.00
LCL084-30.00
LCL085-10.00
LCL086-10.0023.6690.8610269.901023.669932.09111,861.0413
LCL087-10.000.540.54812.79143.83101.0381.8680.85920.77149.88130.2710
LCL088-10.001,125.881,125.8810
LCL089-10.0092.67350.35101,053.521092.6792,129.6014
LCL090-10.001,296.651,296.6512
LCL091-10.0080.14209.651180.1411110.0410255.4210
LCL093-10.00
LCL094-10.00
LCL095-10.00
LCL096-10.000.060.0640.0770.1370.0740.0740.0860.0770.0770.077
LCL097-10.000.060.0640.0770.0650.0640.0740.0650.0670.0770.077
LCL098-10.000.060.0640.0670.0650.0640.0740.0650.0670.0670.067
LCL100-10.00
LCL101-10.000.090.0970.331176.91100.1060.13648.0890.32104.25110.7310
LCL102-10.000.530.5371.74112,172.96111.8273.4373.40117.56116.8511
LCL103-10.00378.301,212.63101,256.2815378.309624.239
LCL104-10.000.070.0760.3511146.60100.0960.116221.66101.35113.67111.1310
LCL106-10.000.060.0640.0670.0770.0640.0740.0970.0670.0670.067
LCL107-10.000.060.0650.0893.1490.0650.0754.9390.1090.1590.119
LCL108-10.000.080.0870.951290.79110.1370.1871,583.89111.65123.38125.9712
LCL110-10.000.490.7770.4911101.69102.5574.597254.13101.14113.02114.5211
LCL111-10.000.060.0650.0780.2780.0750.0850.1270.0780.0880.088
LCL112-10.007.187.18813.881343.25881.17842.5513135.4413359.7613
LCL113-10.00
LCL114-10.00
LCL115-10.00
LCL116-10.00
LCL117-10.000.060.0630.0650.0650.0630.0630.0650.0650.0650.065
LCL118-10.000.060.0670.13118.63100.0970.1376.5790.36111.03110.2110
LCL120-10.000.060.0660.0790.7990.0760.0765.3490.0790.0890.089
LCL121-10.001,562.341,562.3412
LCL122-10.00
LCL123-10.000.860.86102.311635.2110123.50104.221674.9916
LCL126-10.000.060.0640.0670.0770.0640.0640.0970.0670.0770.067
LCL127-10.00
LCL128-10.00
LCL129-10.0051.19525.1611313.791651.19999.819899.46161,834.3715
LCL130-10.000.060.0650.0680.2380.0650.0751.2780.0780.0780.078
LCL131-10.00182.28182.28111,296.8716901.96101,797.0110
LCL166-10.00
LCL169-10.000.060.0610.0610.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0610.061
LCL170-10.000.060.0610.0610.0610.0630.0630.0610.0610.0610.061
LCL171-10.000.060.0610.0610.0710.0630.0630.0610.0610.0610.061
LCL172-10.000.060.0610.0710.0610.0630.0630.0610.0610.0610.061
LCL173-10.000.060.0610.0610.0610.0630.0630.0610.0610.0610.061
LCL174-10.000.060.0620.0630.0630.0620.0620.0630.0630.0630.083
LCL175-10.000.060.0610.0610.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0610.061
LCL176-10.000.060.0620.0630.0630.0620.0620.0630.0630.0630.063
LCL177-10.000.060.0630.0650.0750.0630.0630.0650.0650.0650.085
LCL178-10.000.060.0630.0650.0750.0630.0630.0650.0650.0650.065
LCL182-10.000.110.1162.30110.2160.23612.071129.761119.6611
LCL185-10.000.060.0620.0730.0630.0620.0620.0630.0630.0630.063
LCL186-10.000.060.0620.0630.0630.0620.0620.0630.0630.0730.063
LCL187-10.000.060.0630.0650.0750.0630.0630.0650.0650.0650.065
LCL188-10.000.060.0630.0650.0650.0630.0630.0650.0650.0650.065
LCL189-10.000.060.0630.0650.0750.0630.0630.0650.1050.0650.065
LCL190-10.000.060.0620.0630.0630.0620.0620.0630.0630.0630.063
LCL191-10.00
LCL192-10.000.060.0640.0870.2170.0740.0740.2470.0870.0970.087
LCL193-10.000.060.0630.0650.0750.0630.0630.0650.0650.0750.065
LCL194-10.000.060.0640.0760.0860.0640.0640.0760.0760.0760.076
LCL195-10.000.130.1360.721040.9490.2460.26683.5992.23104.95102.9810
LCL196-10.000.720.728111.94146.10089.608
LCL197-10.000.060.0630.0650.0650.0630.0630.0650.0650.0750.065
LCL198-10.001.311.318174.89148.73811.458
LCL199-10.000.070.0760.1192.0680.1360.1560.8580.1990.3390.239
LCL200-10.000.060.0650.0770.0860.0750.0750.0760.0770.0770.077
LCL201-10.000.090.0960.1592.7180.1860.2061.1980.2790.5090.339
LCL202-10.000.140.1470.391012.6091.0871.4272.2481.28102.87101.8010
LCL203-10.000.090.0960.1592.7480.1860.2061.1980.2890.5190.349
LCL204-10.000.090.0960.1592.7280.1860.2061.1980.2890.5090.339
LCL205-10.000.180.1870.451014.6491.2271.6172.4881.50103.32102.1210
LCL206-10.000.090.0960.1792.7480.1860.2061.2180.2890.5190.349
LCL207-10.000.060.0650.0770.0960.0750.0850.0760.0770.0870.077
LCL208-10.000.440.44715.01122.3573.027130.4112312.6412241.3712
LCL211-10.000.070.0750.21915.3990.0850.09525.0490.4090.6990.469
LCL212-10.000.120.1260.711042.1090.2460.26686.7292.23104.77102.9810
LCL213-10.000.080.0850.33928.8790.1050.10540.9990.6591.2190.779
LCL215-10.000.120.1260.681039.1390.2260.25681.9092.11104.49102.7810
LCL216-10.000.070.0750.19913.10090.0850.08525.8990.3490.6390.419
LCL221-10.00460.67460.6711
LCL223-10.00
LCL224-10.001,029.691,029.6911
LCL225-10.001,831.531,831.5311
LCL226-10.000.060.0620.0630.0630.0620.0620.0630.0630.0730.063
LCL234-10.002.292.299432.311580.429119.679
LCL236-10.000.060.0630.0650.0650.0630.0630.0650.0650.0750.075
LCL237-10.0012.9512.95101,237.06101,973.3310
LCL238-10.000.060.0650.0880.2170.0750.0750.2670.1080.1180.108
LCL250-10.0016.2216.2292,227.3915415.119620.569
LCL256-10.00
LCL257-10.000.070.0770.08110.93100.1070.106156.38110.09110.13110.3511
LCL355-10.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
LCL356-10.000.060.0620.0640.0640.0620.0620.0640.0640.0640.064
LCL357-10.000.060.0620.0640.0640.0620.0620.0640.0640.0640.064
LCL358-10.000.060.0640.0660.0660.0640.0640.0660.0660.0660.066
LCL360-10.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
LCL361-10.000.060.0640.0670.0870.0640.0640.0660.0670.0670.066
LCL362-10.000.060.0640.0670.0870.0640.0640.0970.0670.0670.077
LCL363-10.000.090.0960.161036.27100.1260.14623.9090.28100.56100.4810
LCL364-10.0041.5941.599468.121572.158109.128
LCL366-10.001,764.511,764.519
LCL367-10.00
LCL370-10.00
LCL371-10.00
LCL373-10.00
LCL378-10.00742.26742.26151,806.649
LCL380-10.00
LCL381-10.00
LCL382-10.00
LCL384-10.00
LCL385-10.00
LCL386-10.00
LCL387-10.00
LCL390-10.00
LCL391-10.00
LCL396-10.00
LCL397-10.000.310.3170.5011755.61110.8771.437509.36101.39113.52113.1211
LCL398-10.000.060.0630.0660.0660.0630.0630.0660.0660.0660.066
LCL399-10.002,004.412,004.419
LCL400-10.00
LCL401-10.00
LCL402-10.00
LCL403-10.00
LCL404-10.00
LCL405-10.00
LCL414-10.000.060.0620.0630.0740.0620.0620.0630.0640.0640.064
LCL416-10.0097.9297.92101,031.9116437.69101,148.6110
LCL429-20.000.060.0640.0680.0780.0640.0740.1080.0680.0780.078
LCL430-20.000.060.0640.0680.0780.0640.0640.1080.0680.0780.078
LCL432-20.000.060.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.061
LCL433-20.000.060.0650.0660.0660.0750.0750.0660.0660.0660.066
LCL435-20.000.060.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.061
LCL436-20.000.060.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.061
LCL437-20.000.050.0510.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.061
LCL438-20.000.060.0620.0640.0640.0620.0620.0640.0640.0640.064
LCL439-20.000.060.0640.0650.0650.0650.0650.0650.065
LCL440-20.000.060.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.060
LCL441-20.000.050.0520.0630.0630.0630.0630.0630.0630.0630.063
LCL443-20.000.060.0660.0880.258113.229182.3491.5180.0780.0780.078
LCL445-20.000.060.0640.0660.0650.0630.0630.0650.0660.0660.066
LCL446-20.000.060.0620.0630.0640.0620.0720.0630.0640.0640.064
LCL447-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
MGT001-10.000.080.081016.7343
MGT003-10.000.070.0767.31193.2719
MGT006-10.000.060.0660.1628
MGT008-10.000.060.0640.10200.9820
MGT009-10.000.060.0640.09201.0320
MGT010-10.000.060.0660.7933
MGT015-10.000.060.0640.102315.4823
MGT032-20.000.060.0660.061341.75130.07130.3413114.1713
MGT036-30.000.060.0630.0690.1290.0690.0690.069
MSC005-10.000.060.0640.0680.0680.0640.0640.0980.0680.0780.078
NUM001-10.000.060.0630.0750.0750.0730.0630.0650.0650.0650.065
NUM002-10.000.060.0630.0860.0860.0730.0730.1560.0760.0760.076
NUM003-10.000.060.0630.0760.0760.0630.0630.1360.0660.0760.076
NUM004-10.000.060.0630.0760.0860.0730.0730.1360.0760.0760.076
NUM019-10.000.060.0620.0630.0630.0630.0630.0630.063
NUM020-10.000.060.0630.0640.0640.0640.0640.0640.064
NUM023-10.000.060.0620.0720.0620.0620.0620.0620.062
NUM024-10.000.100.1050.2279.18712.92614.18614.5670.2970.3870.327
NUM025-10.000.060.0620.0630.0630.0630.0630.0730.063
NUM283-1.0050.0026.3926.3939170.0348
PLA001-10.000.070.0760.36110.0860.1363.911119.171120.4611
PLA003-10.000.060.0660.0660.1460.1460.0660.0760.066
PLA006-10.000.060.0620.0650.0750.0650.0750.065
PLA007-10.000.250.25108.6722
PLA016-10.000.110.1192.3621
PLA017-10.000.060.0640.0789.9580.0980.0980.108
PLA019-10.000.080.0880.8919
PLA020-10.000.060.0610.0630.0630.0630.0630.073
PLA022-10.000.080.0870.50134.751330.1013231.3513
PLA022-20.000.060.0670.08131.591310.1813223.0613
PUZ008-10.000.060.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.071
PUZ008-30.00437.13437.1340
PUZ038-10.000.060.0610.0710.0710.0610.0710.0710.071
PUZ039-10.00
PUZ040-10.00
PUZ042-10.00
PUZ047-10.000.060.0670.0870.1170.1070.0670.0670.077
RNG001-20.002.232.23483.4513223.7813320.0613501.0613
RNG001-30.000.060.0640.6314570.19140.74142.8514
RNG001-50.001.991.994381.951126.321136.551135.2511
RNG005-20.000.060.0610.0640.0840.0740.0640.064
RNG006-20.000.070.0720.0750.0750.0850.0750.075
RNG037-20.000.060.0620.0750.0650.0750.0650.065
RNG038-20.000.060.1240.0660.0760.0660.0760.0660.066
RNG039-20.0037.0937.093454.6991,044.1961,092.286327.979365.319345.159
SET818-20.000.060.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0500.0600.0600.060
SET819-20.000.060.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.060
SET824-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
SET826-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
SET827-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
SET828-20.000.060.0610.0720.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
SET829-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
SET832-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
SET833-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
SET835-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
SET836-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.072
SET846-20.000.060.0630.0630.0630.0630.0630.0630.063
SET850-20.000.060.0610.0820.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
SET859-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
SWV011-10.000.060.0610.0720.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
SWV242-20.000.060.0650.0680.0780.0640.0640.0670.0780.0680.068
SWV256-20.000.060.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.061
SWV257-20.000.060.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.061
SWV258-20.000.060.0630.0740.0640.0640.0640.0640.064
SWV259-20.000.060.0630.0630.0630.0630.0630.0630.063
SWV263-20.000.060.0620.0630.0630.0630.0630.0630.063
SWV264-20.000.060.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.061
SWV265-20.000.060.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.061
SWV266-20.000.060.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.061
SWV267-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
SWV269-20.000.060.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.061
SWV273-20.000.060.0630.0640.0740.0630.0630.0640.0640.0640.064
SWV277-20.000.060.0620.0730.0630.0620.0620.0630.0630.0630.063
SWV279-20.000.060.0670.07100.1192.7282.9681.71100.0790.0690.069
SWV280-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
SWV299-20.000.060.06120.07141.93110.08120.20124.0712
SWV309-20.000.060.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.061
SWV310-20.000.060.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.061
SWV312-20.000.060.0610.0610.0610.0710.0610.0610.061
SWV320-20.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
SWV330-20.000.060.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.060
SWV331-20.000.060.0620.0650.0750.0650.0650.065
SWV333-20.000.060.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.060
SWV334-20.000.060.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0700.0600.0600.060
SWV336-20.000.060.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.060
SWV341-20.000.060.0620.0620.0620.0720.0620.0620.062
SWV349-20.000.050.0500.0600.0600.0600.0600.0500.0600.0600.060
SWV350-20.000.050.0500.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.060
SWV351-20.000.060.0600.0700.0600.0600.0600.0500.0600.0600.060
SWV355-20.000.060.0670.0670.1570.1470.0770.0670.067
SWV356-20.000.060.0620.0620.0620.0620.0620.0620.062
SWV357-20.000.060.0620.0630.0630.0630.0630.0630.063
SWV358-20.000.060.0670.0770.1570.1470.0670.0670.067
SWV364-20.000.060.0620.0630.0630.0630.0630.0630.063
SYN033-10.000.060.0610.0630.0630.0630.0630.063
SYN035-10.000.060.0620.0660.0660.0660.0660.066
SYN048-10.000.060.0600.0600.0600.0600.0700.0600.0600.0600.060
SYN049-10.000.060.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.061
SYN050-10.000.060.0610.0720.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
SYN064-10.000.060.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.060
SYN065-10.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
SYN068-10.000.060.0640.0650.0650.0650.0650.0650.0650.0650.065
SYN079-10.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
SYN310-10.001.679.351212.18121.6761.6364.96929.3495.549
SYN312-10.0019.45112.641319.451487.598137.188156.59884.96821.4210412.011138.4810
SYN336-10.000.060.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.060
SYN338-10.000.060.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.060
SYN339-10.000.060.0600.0700.0600.0600.0700.0600.0600.0600.060
SYN340-10.000.060.0600.0600.0600.0600.0700.0600.0600.0600.060
SYN341-10.000.060.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.060
SYN346-10.000.060.0610.0720.0620.0610.0710.0620.0620.0620.062
SYN553-10.000.060.0650.0991.8993.8190.1290.1790.149
SYN555-10.000.060.0620.0640.0640.0620.0720.0640.0640.0640.064
SYN558-10.000.070.07526.891452.2914138.9014
SYN559-10.000.060.0640.07100.42100.07100.07100.0910
SYN561-10.000.060.0640.07100.43100.06100.07100.0910
SYN562-10.000.060.0610.0630.0630.0630.0630.063
SYN564-10.000.090.0950.1295.3190.1490.1990.199
SYN565-10.0010.2720.65710.27121,055.121116.971232.831275.6312
SYN566-10.000.060.0650.081115.74110.13110.19110.5711
SYN569-10.0020.5944.08820.591526.091568.1415
SYN570-10.000.060.0640.0680.0980.0780.0780.078
SYN572-10.008.188.18629.781239.811264.641256.6512
SYN577-10.001,184.351,184.35171,636.2014
SYN584-10.000.060.0630.0660.0660.0760.0660.066
SYN590-10.000.120.4160.12106.02100.07100.08100.1210
SYN596-10.000.060.0620.0650.0650.0650.0650.065
SYN597-10.000.060.0640.07100.91100.11100.15100.1710
SYN602-10.000.060.0640.0790.3090.0890.0790.079
SYN603-10.000.060.0640.0790.3090.0790.0790.079
SYN618-10.000.620.62612.421222.591247.881266.2212
SYN628-10.000.420.4260.421146.58110.52110.81111.7411
SYN629-10.000.430.5060.431146.98110.53110.83111.7511
SYN632-10.000.262.2980.26134.211316.1713367.7713
SYN651-10.000.060.0640.0760.0760.0740.0840.0660.0760.0660.076
SYN652-10.000.070.0750.1291.6490.1150.1255.5190.1590.2290.199
SYN691-10.000.070.0750.09854.1880.2880.4680.478
SYN715-10.000.070.0750.0895.7490.1090.1490.149
SYN719-10.000.070.0730.0770.2170.0870.0870.087
SYN727-10.000.060.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.0610.061
SYN729-10.000.060.0650.0660.0660.0750.0750.0660.0660.0660.066
SYN731-10.000.060.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.0600.060
SYO611-10.000.060.0610.0630.0630.0630.0630.063
SYO612-10.000.060.0610.0613133.17130.06130.191385.8813
SYO613-10.000.060.0610.062312.8523
SYO632-10.000.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0710.0620.0620.0620.062
SYO633-10.000.060.0650.08201.8120
SYO634-10.000.150.1510
SYO691-1.0000.000.060.0660.0690.8393.1083.4780.3290.0690.0690.069
SYO691-1.0010.000.070.0790.09140.10141.79142,028.2914
COL103-20.250.060.0600.1100.0600.0700.0600.0500.0600.0600.060
LAT271-20.250.060.0610.0620.0620.0610.0610.0620.0620.0620.062
LCL020-10.25
LCL031-10.25
LCL037-10.25
LCL039-10.25
LCL062-10.25
LCL074-10.25
LCL092-10.25388.45484.75122,290.8511388.4510
LCL099-10.25
LCL105-10.25
LCL119-10.25
LCL125-10.25
LCL167-10.25
LCL210-10.251.021.02835.601316.84823.608545.25131,412.56131,475.5313
LCL214-10.250.080.0850.28924.0590.0950.10533.2090.5791.0490.679
LCL217-10.250.070.0750.22918.3790.0850.08534.2990.4490.7990.529
LCL218-10.250.100.1060.1993.7080.2160.2361.6880.3790.6990.459
LCL222-10.25
LCL227-10.25
LCL230-10.250.650.6574.5811444.03102.9073.667977.721022.611154.691135.0011
LCL231-10.250.900.9075.6811536.93103.5074.3871,083.931026.911161.881140.6211
LCL249-10.25
LCL359-10.250.060.0630.0650.0650.0630.0630.0650.0650.0650.065
LCL365-10.25277.93379.4210277.939475.409
LCL368-10.25
LCL369-10.25
LCL372-10.25
LCL375-10.25
LCL376-10.25
LCL379-10.25
LCL383-10.25
LCL388-10.25
LCL389-10.25
LCL392-10.25
LCL393-10.25
LCL394-10.25
LCL444-20.25
MGT002-10.250.070.0769.32193.3119
MGT017-10.250.060.0640.102315.3223
NUM017-10.25163.84163.847
NUM284-1.0140.25
PLA004-10.25494.94494.9415
PLA004-20.25447.29447.2915
PLA005-10.25995.73995.7316
PLA005-20.2527.2327.2316806.6232
PLA009-10.25166.82166.82142,325.7626
PLA009-20.25
PLA010-10.25
PLA011-10.252.972.971475.7429
PLA011-20.2531.9431.9414
PLA012-10.25
PLA013-10.25148.14148.1414
PLA014-10.25952.24952.2415
PLA014-20.25123.91123.9115
PLA015-10.25
PLA018-10.25
PLA021-10.25951.45951.4518
PLA023-10.25
RNG004-30.253.383.384
SYN311-10.250.211.14131.53130.2160.2060.2282.2790.258
SYN333-10.250.060.0620.0660.0660.0660.0660.066
SYN556-10.250.250.25629.491379.1013208.9213337.5113
SYN557-10.250.060.0640.1070.5770.5750.5951.2970.1170.1270.117
SYN563-10.250.354.4170.3510397.15101.01102.01102.2310
SYN588-10.250.060.0620.0630.0730.0630.0730.0630.063
SYN589-10.250.060.0620.0630.0730.0630.0630.0630.063
SYN598-10.250.070.0740.0880.1680.0880.0880.088
SYN599-10.250.100.1050.1090.9090.1190.1290.119
SYN601-10.250.060.0650.1311102.58110.27110.57111.5811
SYN614-10.256.596.5962,008.1314
SYN616-10.250.060.0640.0790.4590.0990.1090.109
SYN617-10.250.220.2260.33102.4790.2860.32672.50100.50100.95100.8010
SYN631-10.259.71266.8079.71121,359.761218.101226.911237.8512
SYN637-10.250.060.0640.0770.1270.0770.0770.077
SYN638-10.250.060.0640.0770.1270.0770.0770.077
SYN646-10.250.080.0850.291174.41110.91111.47112.7211
SYN649-10.250.070.0760.0780.0880.8170.9870.1180.0780.0880.078
SYN653-10.250.61202.4680.6111274.3011780.86111.26112.80116.1211
SYN654-10.250.165.0070.161017.551052.41100.25100.47100.6410
SYN655-10.250.168.1970.161017.541053.40100.29100.47100.6410
SYN688-10.252.284.3162.2811481.611113.851121.431129.4311
SYN689-10.251.652.8561.6511411.161112.231118.591125.3111
SYN702-10.250.060.0630.0760.1760.0760.0760.076
SYN703-10.250.080.0860.119171.0890.4490.7390.819
SYN704-10.250.060.0640.09836.4380.1980.2780.278
SYN705-10.250.080.0860.129172.5690.4190.7490.829
SYN706-10.250.070.0750.1096.3190.1390.1990.219
SYN709-10.250.070.0750.0780.1380.0780.0780.078
SYN711-10.250.060.0630.0740.0740.0740.0740.0740.074
SYN712-10.250.070.0760.109102.5690.3090.5090.629
SYN716-10.250.060.0650.0884.4980.1080.1480.138
SYO691-1.0020.2522.0422.041444.522387.5423
ANA003-20.50
LCL001-10.50
LCL028-10.50
LCL061-10.50
LCL124-10.50
LCL253-10.5058.8058.8010
LCL374-10.50
LCL377-10.50
LCL395-10.50
LCL417-20.50
LCL428-10.50
LCL875-10.50
PLA008-10.50
PUZ050-10.50
SWV014-10.50
SYN600-10.502.802.8071,371.1414
SYN615-10.5040.1240.127
SYN639-10.500.070.0750.6912642.97124.63128.401232.4012
SYN640-10.500.070.0750.7012641.34124.65128.391232.3812
SYN647-10.500.070.0750.281174.33110.88111.47112.7211
SYN707-10.504.584.58623.9812148.5612231.9112470.6712
SYN708-10.504.584.58623.5512147.5112232.0412470.2212
SYN982-10.50
LCL063-10.75
LCL109-10.75
LCL417-10.75
LCL422-10.75
LCL423-10.75
LCL927-10.75
LCL928-10.75
LCL929-10.75
GEO001-41.00
LCL419-11.00
LCL420-11.00
LCL421-11.00
LCL424-11.00
LCL425-11.00
LCL426-11.00
LCL427-11.00
LCL926-11.00
ROB025-11.00
SYO691-1.0031.00
SYO691-1.0041.00
SYO691-1.0051.00
ProblemRatingCM-TABXH-1-5H-1H-2H-3H-4H-5H-6H-7H-8H-9CMProverSETHEOslazyCop 0.1SATCop 0.1
Totals of 562:430421413390250239236327365355351414387338394